nkoch/model_mutations_2022
2
0
Fork 0
Code Issues Pull Requests Releases Wiki Activity

split some sentences in discussion for (hopefully) better clarity

Browse Source
This commit is contained in:
sonnenberg 2022-06-28 11:58:28 +02:00
parent 11d574c806
commit 6afdd7843d
1 changed files with 11 additions and 5 deletions
Show Stats Download Patch File Download Diff File Expand all files Collapse all files

16
manuscript.tex
View File

@ -368,7 +368,7 @@ Mutations in \Kv are associated with episodic ataxia type~1 (EA1) and have been
\notels{change AUC to "fI-AUC" or "AUC of the fI-curve"} \notenk{Done for Discussion, not sure if this makes sense to do in the results as well}
To compare the effects of changes to properties of ionic currents on neuronal firing of different neuron types, a diverse set of conductance-based models were simulated. Changes to single ionic current properties, as well as known episodic ataxia type~1 associated \Kv mutations showed consistent effects on the rheobase across cell types, whereas the effects on AUC of the steady-state fI-curve depend on cell type. Our results demonstrate that LOF and GOF on the biophysical level cannot be uniquely transfered to the level of neuronal firing. The effects depend on the properties of the other currents expressed in a cell and are therefore depending on cell type.
To compare the effects of changes to properties of ionic currents on neuronal firing of different neuron types, a diverse set of conductance-based models was simulated. Changes to single ionic current properties, as well as known episodic ataxia type~1 associated \Kv mutations showed consistent effects on the rheobase across cell types, whereas the effects on AUC of the steady-state fI-curve depend on cell type. Our results demonstrate that LOF and GOF on the biophysical level cannot be uniquely transfered to the level of neuronal firing. The effects depend on the properties of the other currents expressed in a cell and are therefore depending on cell type.
%Using a set of diverse conductance-based neuronal models, the effects of changes to properties of ionic currents on neuronal firing were determined to be heterogenous for the AUC of the steady state fI curve but more homogenous for rheobase. For a known channelopathy, episodic ataxia type~1 associated \Kv mutations, the effects on rheobase are consistent across model cell types, whereas the effects on AUC depend on cell type. Our results demonstrate that LOF and GOF on the biophysical level cannot be uniquely transfered to the level of neuronal firing. The effects depend on the properties of the other currents expressed in a cell and are therefore depending on cell type.
@ -376,21 +376,27 @@ To compare the effects of changes to properties of ionic currents on neuronal fi
\subsection*{Neuronal Diversity}
%\notejb{Before we start questioning our models we should have a paragraph pointing out that neurons are diverse and differ in their ion channel composition. Cite for example those recent Nature/Science papers where Phillip Berens is part of on neuron types in cerebellum. Thomas Euler Retina ganglien cell types. Then the paper defining Regular/fast spiking interneurons. And many more... like Eve Marder as you have it in a paragraph further down.}\\
%\notenk{Added this section - it needs more work, but what do you think of the direction I'm going?} \notenk{Also I'm not sure which regular/fast spiking interneuron paper you mean}\\
Advances in high-throughput techniques have enable large-scale investigation into single-cell properties across the CNS \citep{Poulin2016} that have revealed large diversity in neuronal gene expression, morphology and neuronal types in the motor cortex \citep{Scala2021}, neocortex \cite{Cadwell2016, Cadwell2020}, GABAergic neurons \citep{Huang2019} and interneruons \citep{Laturnus2020}, cerebellum \citep{Kozareva2021}, spinal cord \citep{Alkaslasi2021}, visual cortex \citep{Gouwens2019} as well as the retina \citep{Baden2016, Voigt2019, Berens2017, Yan2020a, Yan2020b}.
The nervous system consists of a vastly diverse and heterogenous collection of neurons with variable properties and characteristics including diverse combinations and expression levels of ion channels which are vital for neuronal firing dynamics.
Advances in high-throughput techniques have enabled large-scale investigation into single-cell properties across the CNS \citep{Poulin2016} that have revealed large diversity in neuronal gene expression, morphology and neuronal types in the motor cortex \citep{Scala2021}, neocortex \cite{Cadwell2016, Cadwell2020}, GABAergic neurons \citep{Huang2019} and interneruons \citep{Laturnus2020}, cerebellum \citep{Kozareva2021}, spinal cord \citep{Alkaslasi2021}, visual cortex \citep{Gouwens2019} as well as the retina \citep{Baden2016, Voigt2019, Berens2017, Yan2020a, Yan2020b}.
% Functional differences: reg/fat spiking, Ephys, models
Diversity across neurons is not limited to gene expression and can also be seen electrophysiologically \citep{Tripathy2017, Gouwens2018, Tripathy2015, Scala2021, Cadwell2020, Gouwens2019, Baden2016, Berens2017} with correlations existing between gene expression and electrophysiological properties \citep{Tripathy2017}. At the ion channel level, diversity exists not only between the specific ion channels cell types express but heterogeneity also exists in ion channel expression levels within cell types \citep{marder_multiple_2011, goaillard_ion_2021,barreiro_-current_2012}. As ion channel properties and expression levels are key determinents of neuronal dynamics and firing \citep{Balachandar2018, Gu2014, Zeberg2015, Aarhem2007, Qi2013, Gu2014a, Zeberg2010, Zhou2020, Kispersky2012} neurons with different ion channel properties and expression levels display different firing properties.
Taken together, the nervous system consists of a vastly diverse and heterogenous collection of neurons with variable properties and characteristics including diverse combinations and expression levels of ion channels which are vital for neuronal firing dynamics.
%Taken together, the nervous system consists of a vastly diverse and heterogenous collection of neurons with variable properties and characteristics including diverse combinations and expression levels of ion channels which are vital for neuronal firing dynamics.
\notels{with our models we tried to get this diversity and it's relevant}
To capture the diversity in neuronal ion channel expression and its relevance in the outcome of ion channel mutations, multiple neuronal models with different ionic currents and underlying firing dynamics are used here.
To capture the diversity in neuronal ion channel expression and its relevance in the outcome of ion channel mutations, multiple neuronal models with different ionic currents and underlying firing dynamics are \notels{were(?)} used here.
\subsection*{Ionic Current Environments Determine the Effect of Ion Channel Mutations}
Although, to our knowledge, no comprehensive evaluation of how ionic current environment and cell type affect the outcome of ion channel mutations, comparisons between the effects of such mutations in certain cells have been reported. For instance, mutations in the SCN1A gene encoding \(\textrm{Na}_{\textrm{V}}\textrm{1.1}\) result in epileptic phenotypes by selective hypoexcitability of inhibitory but not excitatory neurons in the cortex resulting in circuit hyperexcitability \citep{Hedrich14874}. In CA3 of the hippocampus, mutation of \(\textrm{Na}_{\textrm{V}}\textrm{1.6}\) similarly results in increased excitability of pyramidal neurons and decreased excitability of parvalbumin positive interneurons \cite{makinson_scn1a_2016}. Additionally, the L858H mutation in \(\textrm{Na}_\textrm{V}\textrm{1.7}\), associated with erythermyalgia, has been shown to cause hypoexcitability in sympathetic ganglion neurons and hyperexcitability in dorsal root ganglion neurons \citep{Waxman2007, Rush2006}. The differential effects of L858H \(\textrm{Na}_\textrm{V}\textrm{1.7}\) on firing is dependent on the presence or absence of another sodium channel \(\textrm{Na}_\textrm{V}\textrm{1.8}\) \citep{Waxman2007, Rush2006}. In a modelling study, it was found that altering the sodium conductance in 2 stomatogastric ganglion neuron models from a population models decreases rheobase in both models, however the initial slope of the fI curves (proportional to AUC of the fI-curve) is increased in one model and decreased in the other suggesting that the magnitude of other currents in these models (such as \(\textrm{K}_\textrm{d}\)) determines the effect of a change in sodium current \citep{Kispersky2012}. These findings, in concert with our findings emphasize that the ionic current environment in which a channelopathy occurs is vital in determining the outcomes of the channelopathy on firing.
To our knowledge, no comprehensive evaluation of how ionic current environment and cell type affect the outcome of ion channel mutations have been reported. But comparisons between the effects of such mutations between certain cell types were described. For instance,
the R1628H mutation in SCN1A results in selective hyperexcitability of cortical pyramidal neurons, but causes hypoexcitability of adjacent inhibitory GABAergic neurons
% mutations in the SCN1A gene encoding \(\textrm{Na}_{\textrm{V}}\textrm{1.1}\) result in epileptic phenotypes by selective hypoexcitability of inhibitory but not excitatory neurons in the cortex resulting in circuit hyperexcitability
\citep{Hedrich14874}. In CA3 of the hippocampus, mutation of \(\textrm{Na}_{\textrm{V}}\textrm{1.6}\) similarly results in increased excitability of pyramidal neurons and decreased excitability of parvalbumin positive interneurons \cite{makinson_scn1a_2016}. Additionally, the L858H mutation in \(\textrm{Na}_\textrm{V}\textrm{1.7}\), associated with erythermyalgia, has been shown to cause hypoexcitability in sympathetic ganglion neurons and hyperexcitability in dorsal root ganglion neurons \citep{Waxman2007, Rush2006}. The differential effects of L858H \(\textrm{Na}_\textrm{V}\textrm{1.7}\) on firing is dependent on the presence or absence of another sodium channel \(\textrm{Na}_\textrm{V}\textrm{1.8}\) \citep{Waxman2007, Rush2006}. In a modelling study, it was found that altering the sodium conductance in 2 stomatogastric ganglion neuron models from a population models decreases rheobase in both models, however the initial slope of the fI curves (proportional to AUC of the fI-curve) is increased in one model and decreased in the other suggesting that the magnitude of other currents in these models (such as \(\textrm{K}_\textrm{d}\)) determines the effect of a change in sodium current \citep{Kispersky2012}. These findings, in concert with our findings emphasize that the ionic current environment in which a channelopathy occurs is vital in determining the outcomes of the channelopathy on firing.
Cell type specific differences in ionic current properties are important in the effects of ion channel mutations, however within a cell type heterogeneity in channel expression levels exists and it is often desirable to generate a population of neuronal models and to screen them for plausibility to biological data in order to capture neuronal population diversity \citep{marder_multiple_2011}. The models we used here are originally generated by characterization of current gating properties and by fitting of maximal conductances to experimental data \citep{pospischil_minimal_2008, ranjan_kinetic_2019, alexander_cerebellar_2019, otsuka_conductance-based_2004}. This practice of fixing maximal conductances based on experimental data is limiting as it does not reproduce the variability in channel expression and neuronal firing behaviour of a heterogeneous neuron population \citep{verma_computational_2020}. For example, a model derived from the mean conductances in a sub-population of stomatogastric ganglion "one-spike bursting" neurons fires 3 spikes instead of 1 per burst due to an L shaped distribution of sodium and potassium conductances \citep{golowasch_failure_2002}.
Multiple sets of current conductances can give rise to the same patterns of activity also termed degeneracy and differences in neuronal dynamics may only be evident with perturbations \citep{marder_multiple_2011, goaillard_ion_2021}.